top of page

Ina Forsman

Nov 4
7 min read

Singer-Songwriter from Finland


"If you think it's ok to use AI in music creation, then you should be ok with everyone knowing you did."

Ina Forsman

Female singer performs on a red-lit stage with mic, band behind her, under warm spotlights; Nord Stage 3 keyboard visible.

Photo: Eric Despres


The first time she came across AI music, it was a joke. Somebody in the van had an app, and on the long drives between gigs the band used it to kill time. Nobody laughs about it any more, she says. She doesn’t know a single musician who does.


What I like about her answers is that she isn’t only angry. She’s precise. She doesn’t ask for AI music to disappear; she thinks it’s too late for that. She asks for a label, so listeners can choose, and for a different price, because a song that took a few sentences shouldn’t earn what a song that took thousands of euros and years of work earns.


And there’s one part of her work she isn’t worried about at all. I’ll let her tell you which.



Let's start with you.

Tell me a little about yourself and your relationship with music. What do you do, and what does making music mean to you personally?

I'm a Finnish Soul singer-songwriter. I've been touring around Europe for over a decade. I've released five studio albums and a few live albums. My music is all about old school soul, powerful vocals and dynamic, organic arrangements played by real instruments and musicians. Writing lyrics, singing, and performing are what I'm best at, and what I was born to do. 


When did AI first become something you actually started thinking about in relation to music?

I remember being on tour and someone fooling around with some app that could make AI versions of released songs or create something completely new. I remember feeling shocked about this new technology, I couldn't believe it. It felt as scary as it was funny at the time, as we were using it as a joke to kill time on our long drives. I think that's how the whole thing felt for me first, just this new trick to use for laughs. It all changed very quickly. We don't play around with AI anymore, I don't know any musician who finds it funny these days.


Do you currently use AI tools in your own work?

I don't use AI in any part of my songwriting or production process, and I'm not planning to do that at any point. I'm making music inspired by 60s and 70s Soul music, and I'm working with very talented musicians who always strive for a very authentic and organic sound. We have no need for AI, because we love what we're doing and we're good at it. 


Where do you personally draw the line?

I do not think AI should be in any part of the creative process of making a song without there being some type of mark on the song that it was made with AI. If you think it's ok to use AI in music creation, then you should be ok with everyone knowing you did. 


What does “making music” actually mean to you in the age of generative AI?

Making music is beautiful, painful, and one of the most wholesome ways to deal with the weight of the world. Sometimes it takes a long time, sometimes magical things happen in the matter of minutes or hours. A new song can be the easiest, most natural thing that just comes out of you when you least expect it, or it can be this serious piece of work that haunts you for months and months until you figure it out. You cannot create without sometimes being lost and uninspired. 


AI is always ready, a new song just a few words and clicks away. That is not real creation. It's something else. 


There is a huge difference between going through the creative process alone or with other musicians, versus going through it with the help of AI. These are two completely different things, and it should be acknowledged thoroughly in all platforms where music can be found. 


What excites you about AI — and what worries you?

I just wish that we'd use technology to help us with research, learning, organising and the kind of stuff that takes time away from being creative and doing art. Why are we "saving time" by making art with AI, when we could save time with AI doing all the other stuff, so we could spend more time doing beautiful things? 


I'm worried AI wil become this easy way out for new musicians and soon it will be so normalized that we lose the difference with actually making music, and prompting AI to do it for you. But these are two completely different things. Real musicians deserve their flowers, and AI artists can go ahead and create their own lane as it's too late to stop them now, but they should not scam people by making them believe their music was created by humans.


What do you think AI will do to the music business itself?

AI music becoming normalized is ruining everything for everyone. I don't see anything good in it. Normal people can't hear a difference between real and AI music anymore, so it's all mixed on streaming platforms already. Small artists have never made much money on streaming platforms, and now it's just becoming harder and harder because we're competing against something that's not real.


Also, AI music is setting unrealistic standards for music productions. Vocals especially are unrealistically perfect, as they have been carved from thousands of amazing singers of our time. Once people get too used to this sound, they will start to critisize real singers and musicians. I think people are already doing that. 


Where do you stand on copyright, consent, and AI training?

If you use AI to make songs, there should be a label on that song, so people are informed. This way people who are ok with AI music can go ahead and listen to it, but people who don't want to hear it can be informed and switch to another song when they see the AI label.


I don't think it's fair for AI music getting the same money as real music. Even the smallest artists spend thousands of euros on producing just one song, and take often years to be able to break even. Someone making a song with a few sentences written as prompt on a computer are not equal to that, which is why they should not be treated as such. You wanna save time and money by using AI? Cool, then you don't need as much money back either. 


Imagine someone is 16 years old today and dreams of becoming a musician.

I would tell them to stay away from AI, and then I would take them to a vinyl store and play them some good music to proof that there is no computer that could ever create something that a human heart can.


Fast-forward five years.

What do you think the music world will look like?

I'm afraid in five years real and AI music will be all mixed up unless we get some regulations and laws around it. I'm tired of musicians being the only ones trying to fight against it, when the general public doesn't give a shit, or at least is very non-chalant about it. We're broke and already struggling with 100 other industry problems, we can't fight this on our own. 


In five years people will start to notice how all the popular music is generic, squicky clean, over produced and soulless, even more than it's now. But there's no one to blame except ourselves and our growing need for everything to be easy, fast and automatic. I'm afraid people will let this happen, it's already too late to change it. 

But I see many beautiful artists creating new music and breaking boundaries. There's this growing urge for all things analog, and I love to see it, I hope the analog trend grows the same way all this AI shit is.


We will never stop creating things with our own hands and hearts, and there will always be people who will keep on searching and reaching for real artists and connection and the feeling only real music can bring. I have to believe that. 


Finally: The Human Frequency.

What is the one thing about human-made music that you believe AI can never replace?

Two things AI will never be able to touch: Being innovative and bringing live music and shows to people. I mean, never say never but at least for now these two things are only for humans by humans. 


AI copies from stuff that is already created. It will never be able to make something unheard of. AI doesn't take risks and it doesn't go through life like artists do. There is a certain depth it can never reach.


AI artists can't go on tour and play live music for people. That is a connection we still have left. This is one part of my own artistry I'm not worried about, not one bit. I never made much money on streaming anyways, Y'all can have it. But going on tour, playing my songs for other people and making them feel all the feelings under the sun? No one can steal that away from me.




BIO

Born in Finland, now living in Berlin, Ina Forsman discovered her love for music at a very early age. Her undying passion for 60s and 70s Soul and RnB was awakened a bit later in her teenage years, after hearing an Etta James song for the first time. After that, she has been creating her own version of Retro Soul as a woman and a songwriter living in a modern world far away from the origins of her most beloved music style and its creators.

With a voice and style that effortlessly bridge the realms of Soul, Blues, and Jazz, Ina has carved a niche for herself in the international music scene. She has released four studio albums and one live album, and tours around Europe with her Finnish band.

Black-and-white concert photo of a tattooed female singer at a microphone, wearing lace tights and a ruffled skirt on a smoky stage.

Photo: Eric Despres





Social links

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page