Matt Grasley
Recording and mixing engineer with a background as a musician
"I don't see a lot of genuine opportunities or developments that will help the music industry because of AI."
Matt Grasley

Most of the people I've talked to for this series stand in front of the microphone. Matt Grasley sits on the other side of the glass.
That matters to me more than it might look. I don't mix my own songs. Joe Carrell in Nashville does, because there's a last thirty percent I can hear is missing and can't put there myself. Whatever that skill is, it's exactly what a generator promises to make unnecessary: you type, and it comes back finished and mixed. So I wanted to ask someone a few years into that craft, someone who learned it the long way, whether he sees the machine as a shortcut, a threat, or neither.
His answer is firmer than I expected, and more honest than most. He keeps AI out of every recording and every mix. But he doesn't pretend he's never touched it, and the line he draws now is a question he asks himself every time he's tempted. It's a better test than most of the policy documents I've read this year.
Let's start with you.
Tell me a little about yourself and your relationship with music. What do you do, and what does making music mean to you personally?
I’m Matt Grasley. I’m a recording and mixing engineer currently based out of Rochester, NY. Before I really got into recording I played trumpet, guitar, drums and bass and played in a bunch of bands. I started experimenting with recording myself over the COVID-19 pandemic and fell in love with the process. I then went to Omega Studios' School of Applied Recording Arts and Sciences to obtain an audio engineering certificate and started interning at studios. That brought me up to Rochester where I’m freelancing at a few studios now.
When did AI first become something you actually started thinking about in relation to music? Was there a particular tool, song, experience or moment that made you realize: this could really change things?
I had started to think about AI in relation to music around the time Suno started to become popular. That was when I was still in school so most of the discussion regarding it were with my classmates. We all immediately dismissed it as something completely ridiculous, not only because it takes the human out of human expression, but also because of the quality of it. The quality of the audio and the mix and how weird and unnatural it sounded.
Do you currently use AI tools in your own work? If yes, which ones and what do you use them for? This could be anything from songwriting, production and mixing to artwork, video, marketing or administration. If you deliberately don't use AI, I'd be equally interested in why.
I don’t use AI in any of my recording or mixing processes nor do I plan to in the future. I really have no interest in outsourcing my creativity in that way. I resonate a lot with what Thomas Bangalter has shared about his views on AI.
Where do you personally draw the line? Are there things you are happy to let AI assist you with — and things you would never want to hand over to a machine?
When AI first started to become mainstream I was using it a lot to do research or help me plan trips and such. Recently though when I’m tempted to just AI something I’ll ask myself if this is something that I can’t do myself, or am I just being lazy? That has helped motivate me to actually use my brain and critical thinking to learn and solve a problem. In the age of AI I think all of our critical thinking skills are at risk of being outsourced to AI. When it came to how I recorded or mixed it was always off limits to use AI. Going back to what Thomas Bangalter said, sitting down and trying different things, figuring out what works for one thing but doesn't work for another is where the fun and creativity is at. And I think that's what makes a great recording/mixing engineer is someone who has had the experience and knowledge from trial and error.
What does “making music” actually mean to you in the age of generative AI? If someone enters a prompt and an AI generates the composition, instruments, vocals and production, do you consider the result a piece of art in the same sense as a song written and performed by people? Why or why not?
I think that music is human expression, expressed by a human being through this artform of music. When you add AI into the equation you are outsourcing that expression to something that is not human. I don't consider AI music actually art in any way.
What excites you about AI — and what worries you? Do you see opportunities that could genuinely help musicians and producers? And on the other side, what developments concern you most?
AI worries me more than it excites me. Especially here in the States with the data centers taking over. I don't see a lot of genuine opportunities or developments that will help the music industry because of AI.
There is a huge debate around copyright, consent and AI training. Where do you stand? Should AI companies be allowed to train their models on existing recordings and compositions? Should artists have to opt in? And if their work contributes to an AI model, should they be credited or compensated?
AI companies should be allowed to train their models on existing recordings as long as they have permission to do so. Artists should definitely have the option to opt in or opt out and they definitely should be compensated.
Fast-forward five years. What do you think the music world will look like? Will audiences care whether a song was made by humans or AI? And do you think we'll even be able to tell the difference?
I think five years from now we are going to see a rise in AI music but also a greater or equal push back against AI music. Considering how far AI has advanced in the past few years, I think it will be harder to distinguish AI music from real human made music.
Finally: The Human Frequency. What is the one thing about human-made music that you believe AI can never replace?
The real human expression and the imperfections that come with that will never be replaced by AI.
Matt Grasley is a recording and mixing engineer with a background as a musician. Trained at Omega Studios' School of Applied Recording Arts & Sciences, Matt freelances at studios in Rochester, NY working with local artists to create real, expressive and unforgettable music.

Social links
Website: www.mattgrasleyaudio.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mattgrasleyaudio


Comments